
A True Statement, With Limits
"Every Tequila is a Mezcal"
"Every Tequila is a Mezcal, but not every Mezcal is a Tequila" — the phrase sounds like a handy mnemonic, but it's actually an entire law in shorthand. It's historically accurate, but the moment labeling comes into play, it falls short: a Tequila isn't even allowed to call itself "Mezcal."
Where the Word Mezcal Comes From
Anyone tracing the origin ends up in Nahuatl, the language of the Aztecs. There, "mexcalli" combines "metl," agave, with "ixcalli," cooked. Literally, the word means cooked agave. For centuries, this referred to any spirit made from the roasted hearts of agave, regardless of exactly where in Mexico it was produced.
The town of Tequila in Jalisco was just one of many places with this tradition. What set it apart was a single agave species: the Blue Weber Agave. Add to that a growing trade network. Over time, the local spirit became its own brand. The name Tequila took hold long before any law existed to protect it. As early as 1795, the Spanish Crown reportedly granted the Cuervo family the first official license to produce it—more than a century and a half before the first denomination of origin.
Two Separate Laws From One Root
Today, Tequila and Mezcal are two separately protected names, each governed by its own set of rules. Tequila has followed NOM-006-SCFI-2012 since 1974, overseen by the Consejo Regulador del Tequila. Mezcal has followed NOM-070-SCFI-2016 since 1994, controlled by the Consejo Regulador del Mezcal.
Both laws require three things: a defined territory, one or more approved agave species, and a minimum production process. Anyone distilling outside the Tequila territory can't call their drink Tequila, even if they use the exact same agave. Anyone using the wrong agave inside the Mezcal territory likewise can't label it Mezcal. Internationally, the protection reaches further than most people realize: under the 1978 Lisbon Agreement, more than forty countries recognize the Tequila designation.
Where the Statement Falls Short
Legally speaking, a Tequila is not a Mezcal. Both names are protected denominations of origin, and a label can only ever carry its own name. The truth behind the phrase lies elsewhere: Tequila is a historical special case within a much larger family of agave spirits—and it's from that very family that Mezcal also emerged.
This family extends beyond Mexico's borders. Within the European Union, the 1997 EU–Mexico agreement on spirits protects both names. In Germany, for instance, nothing may be called "Tequila" unless it comes from the protected territory. A German producer could theoretically grow the same agave and distill it the same way—but would still be barred from using the name.
Three Questions for Every Name on This Journey
For every spirit in this family, the same three factors determine its name. First, the territory where it may be produced. Second, the plant it's distilled from. Third, the process prescribed by the relevant standard. Knowing the answers to these three questions immediately explains why Raicilla can't be called Mezcal—and just as easily explains why Sotol belongs to this family anyway, even though it isn't made from agave at all.
The stops ahead work through this family one by one. We'll start with the great Mezcal and its many agaves, then move to its smaller siblings from Jalisco, Sonora, and the north. We'll end with Pulque, which isn't distilled at all.
Why Confusing the Names Gets Expensive
Mixing up these names means confusing words, price categories, and entire flavor profiles. A restaurant that sells Mezcal as Tequila risks running into real trade-law trouble. The same goes in reverse for any seller who swaps the names carelessly.
For travelers, it pays to check the label before buying or ordering. It will always state which name and which standard the drink falls under. This journey walks through, stop by stop, what really lies behind each of these names.
An Eye for the Label
On every properly labeled bottle, exactly one name appears in the end: Tequila or Mezcal, never both together, since the two laws are mutually exclusive. If neither name appears at all, it's worth taking a second look at the origin and ingredient list.
Once you understand the family, you'll see every label differently. That's exactly what the stops ahead in this journey are about.