Preparation
- Chill the serving glass. Add the measured ingredients to a shaker.
- Add plenty of solid ice cubes and shake hard for about 10–15 seconds.
- Strain through a Hawthorne strainer into the chilled glass; the shaking ice stays in the shaker.
What does it taste like?
First you taste orange, sweet and bitter at the same time. That comes from the Aperol and the second bitter liqueur, which adds herbal, slightly caramel notes. Then the lemon kicks in and pulls everything sharply together. The bourbon stays in the background, contributing barrel sweetness, though it doesn't get much room: all four parts are equal in size. It's served without ice in the chilled glass and warms up over time. In the finish, the bitterness lingers on the tongue longer than the fruit.
When does it work best?
The Paper Plane works well before a meal, as an aperitif, or as the first drink of the evening. It's bitter, but the lemon and whiskey keep it approachable. Beginners handle it better than a Negroni. If you like Aperol and are looking for something a bit more serious, this is the next step up. Just don't go in expecting something sweet.
What matters
The first time, stick exactly to the four equal parts, meaning 30 milliliters each. A different amaro can be far more bitter, sweet, or menthol-forward, throwing off the balance immediately. Only swap out ingredients once you know the original, and note down any such experiments as your own variation. Shake hard with plenty of ice for about 10–15 seconds, until the drink is well chilled and diluted.

Where the drink comes from
Sam Ross created the Paper Plane in 2007 for Chicago's bar scene. The recipe was refined further afterward. The name comes from a song by M.I.A. that Ross was listening to at the time. The build is borrowed: four ingredients in equal parts is a structure already familiar from the Last Word. Ross swapped out the building blocks. Bourbon and two different bitter liqueurs send the drink in its own direction, distinctly orange-forward. It's exactly this simple formula that makes it easy to remember and easy to recreate.
