Preparation
- Shake the whiskey, lemon juice, syrup, and pasteurized egg white hard with plenty of ice. Hold back the red wine.
- Strain over fresh ice cubes into a chilled tumbler.
- Slowly pour the red wine over the back of a spoon onto the surface.
- Finish with a garnish: lemon or orange zest and a cocktail cherry.
What does it taste like?
On top sits the red wine, and that's what you taste first: dark fruit and a dry, slightly furry feel on the tongue. Underneath waits the sour. Lemon makes it tart, the simple syrup catches the acidity again. The whiskey brings spice and barrel notes along, and at 60 milliliters it's clearly the main ingredient. You won't really taste the small amount of egg white; it just softens the drink and lays a fine foam on top. The further you drink, the more the wine and sour mix together.
When does it work best?
The drink works well after a meal or on a long evening. At 60 milliliters of whiskey it's strong, yet still easy to drink. If you like red wine but feel unsure about straight whiskey, this is a good way in. It also looks great on the table, since the two layers stand out. It's not meant for anything very sweet.
What matters
The red wine goes into the glass only after shaking. Pour it slowly over the back of a bar spoon, close to the surface. That way it settles as a floating layer. If you just dump it in or stir it afterward, you'll end up with a cloudy mixed drink without the nice gradient. Also shake hard, so the egg white forms the fine foam the wine can rest on.

Where the drink comes from
Whiskey sours topped with red wine used to go by several names. Some accounts link them to Chicago. The name New York Sour only became established later. The name alone therefore proves nothing about its origin. What's certain is what happens in the glass: a familiar sour formula of spirit, acid, and sugar gets a floating layer of wine on top. That gives fruit, a bit of tannin, and a different first impression. It's exactly this trick that sets it apart from a plain whiskey sour, and it only costs a spoonful of extra work.
