Skip to content
Gustofolio
Knowledge HubProducersEvents
CaptureCollectionTasteEnjoyShare
Roadmap
Knowledge HubProducersEvents
CaptureCollectionTasteEnjoyShare
Beta roadmapCreate account
Legal NoticePrivacy
ENSign inCreate account
Drinks EncyclopediaLexiconKnowledge JourneysJourneysTopic WorldsTopicsAll ArticlesArticlesCocktail RecipesCocktailsRecipes with drinksRecipes
Encyclopedia/Recipes

American · Snack · 45 min

American Potato Salad with Egg and Pickles

A creamy, slightly sweet-and-sour salad with mayonnaise, mustard, pickle relish, egg and crunchy celery.

As of: 11 October 2026

American Potato Salad with Egg and Pickles

Ingredients

servings

Salad

  • 800 gwaxy potatoes (peeled or thoroughly washed, cut into 1.5 cm cubes)
  • —salt (for the cooking water, generously)
  • 3eggs, hard-boiled (roughly chopped)
  • 2 stalkscelery (finely diced)
  • 1red onion (finely diced)

Dressing

  • 150 gmayonnaise
  • 3 tbspsweet pickle relish (or finely chopped gherkins with ½ tsp sugar)
  • 2 tbspmedium-hot mustard (yellow mustard, e.g. hot dog mustard)
  • ½ tspgarlic powder
  • ½ tspsweet paprika
  • 1 pinchcayenne pepper
  • ½ tspsalt

Vinegar mixture

  • 2 tbspwhite wine vinegar or apple cider vinegar
  • 1 tspsugar
  • 1 tspsalt

Also

  • —black pepper (to taste, for seasoning)
  • —paprika (for dusting, optional)
Time
25 min active · 45 min total · + 2 h resting
Difficulty
easy

How do you like the recipe?

No ratings yet.

Preparation

  1. Put the potatoes in cold, generously salted water, bring to the boil and cook for 12 to 15 minutes until just fork-tender. Drain and place in a large bowl.
  2. Meanwhile, mix the eggs, celery, onion, mayonnaise, relish, mustard, garlic powder, paprika, cayenne and ½ tsp salt in a second bowl. In a small dish, stir the vinegar, sugar and 1 tsp salt until dissolved.
  3. Pour the vinegar mixture over the still-hot potatoes, toss gently and leave to cool for 5 minutes. Lightly mash a few of the potato cubes, which makes the salad creamier.
  4. Fold in the egg and mayonnaise mixture in three batches, leaving about 5 minutes between each. Season with pepper and salt.
  5. Chill the salad for at least 2 hours so the flavours come together, and dust with a little paprika before serving.

Drink with it

  • Pale lager · excellent match

    Pils or pale lager, well chilled

    Bubbles and hop bitterness cut through the mayonnaise, and the freshness suits the vinegar and mustard.

    Pils or Helles: What's the Difference? ↗
  • Vodka · excellent match

    Vodka, ice-cold and neat in small glasses

    Egg, mayonnaise, mustard and pickles come close to an Olivier salad, the classic companion to cold vodka; the clear sip clears the mayonnaise from the palate.

    What Is Vodka? Raw Materials, Flavor, and Cocktails ↗
  • Wheat beer · good match

    Hefeweizen

    Its light fruitiness and soft carbonation round off the sweet-and-sour note without overwhelming the salad.

    Wheat Beer: Where Do Banana and Clove Come From? ↗
  • White wine · good match

    Dry Riesling or Grüner Veltliner

    Fresh acidity stands up to the mayonnaise and egg, and the peppery note of the Veltliner meets the mustard.

    Which wine pairs with food? A simple approach to choosing ↗

Why it pairs well

Vodka with potato salad follows the Eastern European round of potato, egg, pickles and ice-cold clear spirit.

With the same drinks

This pairs well too.

  • Pierogi with Potato and Cheese Filling

    Soft dumplings with a creamy potato and Cheddar filling, fried golden in sage butter and served with soured cream.

    To the recipe ↗
  • Potato Pancakes with Soured Cream (Reibekuchen / Draniki)

    Crisp potato pancakes with a tender centre, fresh from the oil and served with cool soured cream.

    To the recipe ↗
  • Chebureki (Fried Minced-Meat Turnovers)

    Thin, blistered, crisp pastry around a juicy, herb-seasoned meat filling, fried golden in hot oil.

    To the recipe ↗
  • Herring Salad

    Cool, tangy salad of Bismarck herring, potatoes, carrots, gherkin and apple in a creamy mayonnaise and soured cream dressing.

    To the recipe ↗

What's in your cellar?

Gustofolio suggests the right bottle from your own collection for this dish.

Discover Gustofolio ↗

Images generated with AI · Text AI-assisted, editorially reviewed

Gustofolio
Drinks EncyclopediaCocktail RecipesRecipesProducersEventsWine App GuideBeta RoadmapPrivacy PolicyTerms of UseLegal NoticeContact

Can we measure how Gustofolio is used? To do this, we'd load Google Analytics and store a cookie on your device. This helps us see which areas are actually used — nothing more. No content from your collection is transmitted.

None of this happens without your consent, and Gustofolio continues to work fully either way. You can change your decision at any time. Details in the privacy policy.