Skip to content
Gustofolio
Knowledge HubProducersEvents
CaptureCollectionTasteEnjoyShare
Roadmap
Knowledge HubProducersEvents
CaptureCollectionTasteEnjoyShare
Beta roadmapCreate account
Legal NoticePrivacy
ENSign inCreate account
Drinks EncyclopediaLexiconKnowledge JourneysJourneysTopic WorldsTopicsAll ArticlesArticlesCocktail RecipesCocktailsRecipes with drinksRecipes
Encyclopedia/Recipes

German · Starter · 40 min

Herring Salad

Cool, tangy salad of Bismarck herring, potatoes, carrots, gherkin and apple in a creamy mayonnaise and soured cream dressing.

As of: 11 October 2026

Herring Salad

Ingredients

servings

Dressing

  • 8 tbspmayonnaise (for the dressing)
  • 2 tbspsoured cream
  • 2 tbspgherkin pickling liquid (from the gherkin jar)
  • 1 tspmustard
  • —salt, pepper and a pinch of sugar (to taste)

Also

  • 300 gwaxy potatoes
  • 2carrots
  • —salt (for the cooking water)
  • 400 gBismarck herring or matjes fillets (from a jar, well drained)
  • 150 ggherkins (drained; keep 2 tbsp of the pickling liquid)
  • 2tart apples
  • 1red onion
Time
30 min active · 40 min total · + 2 h resting
Difficulty
easy

How do you like the recipe?

No ratings yet.

Preparation

  1. Peel the potatoes and carrots, cut into small cubes, boil in salted water for 10 to 15 minutes until tender, drain and leave to cool completely.
  2. Pat the herring dry, remove any bones if necessary and cut into bite-sized pieces about 1 cm wide.
  3. Peel and core the apples and cut into small cubes, as with the gherkins, and finely dice the onion.
  4. For the dressing, stir the mayonnaise, soured cream, pickling liquid and mustard until smooth and season with salt, pepper and sugar.
  5. Mix the potatoes, carrots, apples, gherkins and onion in a bowl, add the fish and carefully fold in the dressing so the herring pieces do not fall apart.
  6. Leave the salad to infuse in the fridge, covered, for at least 2 hours, ideally overnight, and taste again before serving.

Drink with it

  • Pale lager · excellent match

    Pils or Helles, well chilled

    Carbonation and hop bitterness cut through the mayonnaise, and the acidity of the gherkin and apple stays fresh.

    Pils or Helles: What's the Difference? ↗
  • Vodka · excellent match

    Clear vodka, ice-cold and neat from a shot glass

    The cold, neutral spirit clears salt and fat after every bite, as Korn or vodka has always done with pickled herring.

    What Is Vodka? Raw Materials, Flavor, and Cocktails ↗
  • White wine · good match

    Grüner Veltliner or dry Riesling

    Lively acidity keeps pace with the pickling liquid, and the peppery spice of the Veltliner goes with mustard and onion.

    Which wine pairs with food? A simple approach to choosing ↗
  • Fruit brandy · good match

    Apple brandy, chilled, neat

    The apple note picks up the apple in the salad, and the alcohol loosens the fat in the dressing.

    What is Calvados? Apple brandy with origin ↗

With the same drinks

This pairs well too.

  • Matjes Hausfrauenart (herring fillets in cream sauce)

    Mild matjes herring fillets in a cool sauce of Schmand (soured cream), sour cream, apple, onion and gherkin, served with jacket potatoes.

    To the recipe ↗
  • Potato pancakes with smoked salmon (Kartoffelpuffer)

    Crisp-fried potato pancakes with smoky salmon, cool soured cream and, if you like, apple sauce.

    To the recipe ↗
  • American Potato Salad with Egg and Pickles

    A creamy, slightly sweet-and-sour salad with mayonnaise, mustard, pickle relish, egg and crunchy celery.

    To the recipe ↗
  • Solyanka (Soljanka)

    A robust, sour-salty soup with three kinds of sausage, peppers, gherkins and capers, served with a dollop of soured cream and lemon.

    To the recipe ↗

What's in your cellar?

Gustofolio suggests the right bottle from your own collection for this dish.

Discover Gustofolio ↗

Images generated with AI · Text AI-assisted, editorially reviewed

Gustofolio
Drinks EncyclopediaCocktail RecipesRecipesProducersEventsWine App GuideBeta RoadmapPrivacy PolicyTerms of UseLegal NoticeContact

Can we measure how Gustofolio is used? To do this, we'd load Google Analytics and store a cookie on your device. This helps us see which areas are actually used — nothing more. No content from your collection is transmitted.

None of this happens without your consent, and Gustofolio continues to work fully either way. You can change your decision at any time. Details in the privacy policy.